The 2024 MAMA Awards in Japan, held on November 22 at the Kyocera Dome in Osaka, became a big subject not only for their stunning performances, but also for the controversy surrounding some of their important moments. One outstanding conversation focused on the performance of APT, a collaboration between BLACKPINK‘s Rosé and Bruno Mars. Despite their great reputations, both singers were accused of lip-syncing during their pre-recorded performance, causing heated controversy online.
Many Korean netizens were disappointed that the concert was not live, especially given the hype to their partnership. Fans had great expectations for a live duet displaying Rosé and Bruno Mars’ distinct talents. Instead, they received a polished but pre-recorded performance, sparking speculation that it was lip-synced.
Table of Contents
Netizen Reactions to Rosé and Bruno Mars performance : Praise and Disappointment
Reactions online were divided. Some defended the artists, praising their vocal abilities and dismissing the lip-syncing claims as unfounded. Comments such as “Rosé sings beautifully, and Bruno’s voice is unmatched” and “They’re so good it only sounds like lip-syncing” reflected fans’ admiration. Others expressed disbelief that Bruno Mars, a seasoned performer known for his electrifying live shows, would even be involved in such a controversy.
However, not all fans were forgiving. Some criticized the decision to present a pre-recorded performance at such a prestigious event, particularly when fans had traveled far to witness the live spectacle. A recurring sentiment was frustration over the perceived lack of effort to deliver an authentic live show. Comments like “Why bother with a pre-recorded track?” and “This was a letdown for fans who waited hours for a live moment” echoed the disappointment of those expecting more.
International vs. Local Perspectives
Interestingly, while Korean fans voiced their discontent loudly, international audiences seemed less critical. Many global viewers appreciated the performance for its production quality and the rare collaboration between two powerhouse artists. This contrast highlights the differing expectations and cultural perspectives between local and international fanbases.
The controversy over Rosé and Bruno Mars’ APT performance at the MAMA Awards raises important questions about live performances in major award shows. While the debate continues, it’s clear that fans, especially those who invest time and money to attend events in person, value authenticity and live engagement. For global artists like Bruno Mars and K-pop stars like Rosé, balancing technical perfection with live authenticity will always be a delicate act.
Despite the controversy, the collaboration remains a standout moment in the night’s lineup, underscoring the growing intersection between K-pop and global music icons. Whether live or pre-recorded, such collaborations reflect the increasingly international reach and influence of the K-pop industry.
